Activity for User 854 - Dave Roth - droth33@yahoo.com

avatar
Avatar

Close this Tab when done


142 Comments / 7 Replies Posted

  = Current Round   = Previous Round
Group Round C/R Comment Date Image
26 Oct 17 Comment Thanks Kaylyn..........that makes sense.

That would also test my ability to selectively edit that portion of the image...
Oct 30th
26 Oct 17 Comment Thanks Mervyn,
I'll try to make next months photo a bit brighter :)
Oct 27th
26 Oct 17 Comment Thank you all for the nice welcome.

I took the image back into LR and found some further detail in the shadows..........I tried to avoid adding any more noise than necessary, but here it is.
Oct 19th
26 Oct 17 Comment Thanks Jose
Based on the comments here, I'll find the time to take another look at pulling some detail out of the lower shadows.

BTW, navigation address is:

3600 Prospect Street NW
Washington DC 20007
Oct 13th
26 Oct 17 Comment Very nice............I'm a sucker for images that play with shadows..........I like the 2nd version slightly better. Oct 12th
26 Oct 17 Comment I like this shot because of the close details...It makes you stop and look closer as you might just pass it by with a glance.....out of focus rear boot not a problem........... Oct 11th
26 Oct 17 Comment What a fun image with all the color. I was surprised I can see only one person looking at her phone. :)

The only adjustment I'd consider is that the horizon might be very slightly off.
Oct 11th
26 Oct 17 Comment Belinda,
I've come back to look at this a few times since you posted. I really like it. I like the drama of the color version, but in honesty, it is a bit too much.

I like the BW and might have added even more structure if I processed. I don't think the crop is necessary, as I enjoy as much detail and contrast as possible in a shot such as this.

Nice
Oct 11th
26 Oct 17 Comment Your patience was worth the wait....and giving you time to get the big gun out..... nice shot Oct 11th
26 Oct 17 Comment Good thoughts.........this is especially dark given the black background of the PSA site...

Thanks Bob
Oct 5th
26 Oct 17 Comment Hi Albert,
I just joined the group and making my first try at this type of commentary.....

Overall, I love this scene, but the cloud cover makes it very difficult to come away with a photo worthy of hanging on a wall. When faced with an image like this, my default is to convert to B&W and use contrast to add drama.

My favorite area in the photo is the far right area of mountain silhouette with water in the foreground. I might try a heavy crop to remove the buildings in the center foreground.
Oct 4th

11 comments - 0 replies for Group 26


11 comments - 0 replies Total


20 Images Posted

  = Current Round   = Previous Round
Group 26

Aug 19

Jul 19

Jun 19

Apr 19

Feb 19

Jan 19

Dec 18

Nov 18

Oct 18

Sep 18

Aug 18

Jul 18

Jun 18

May 18

Apr 18

Feb 18

Jan 18

Dec 17

Nov 17

Oct 17

Close this Tab when done