Activity for User 751 - R Gary Butler - rgbutler52@gmail.com

avatar
Avatar

Close this Tab when done


779 Comments / 217 Replies Posted

  = Current Round   = Previous Round
Group Round C/R Comment Date Image
4 Dec 23 Reply Ian, you picked up on one thing that struck me as well - every player is watching the puck. I feel that really helps any viewer end up focusing on the goalie. Thanks for the feedback. Dec 9th
4 Dec 23 Reply The first thing was to clone out the black steel spike using the cloning tool. Then I used the PS magnetic lasso to go across the nearer ground line then up along the right side of the foghorns on the left to the top. I went across the top and down the right side to comp[lete the selection. I made a "Layer via copy." Then I shifted it all to the right. Since the angle of the side of the lighthouse is complete I rebuilt the missing sections of the LH from the complete bottom white and black sections. Lastly I cloned the sky from the right of the LH to the left of the lighthouse. I hope that helps. Dec 8th
4 Dec 23 Comment Vella, I like what you have done with the image. To my eye the change in the Hue of the blocks helps bring them out more as the true subject of the image.

From my experience I tried three things in the Visual Feedback. First (and this is the most important from experience) I cropped to make as many lines as possible flow out of the corners of the image. Second I add a Contrast layer in PS to the blocks to make them stand out even more. Last, I added a Hue/Saturation layer to the bright yellow building to make it less likely to draw the viewers eyes. All three just there for thought. Thanks for sharing this image. Happy Holidays!
Dec 8th
4 Dec 23 Comment Ian, there is a lot to like about this image. I feel that you have done a credible job of
placing the young lady in front of the door given the shadows to her left. I believe that her being brighter than the door helps hold my eyes' focus point on her.

For my taste I would reduce the brightness on her a bit, perhaps making her a bit more "mysterious." I might also suggest that if you have original image at the bottom of the current that you extend a bit farther to fully connect her left arm to the body.

Given that you have not done this much previously I would say you are off to a good start. Happy Holidays!
Dec 8th
4 Dec 23 Comment Bill, very nicely done and visually pleasing. My original thought when I examined both images was that I would have cloned out the big base of the near pillar put the water level at the original ground level. But the more I look at it the more I think you did the right thing. Raising the water level helped remove the bright spot at the right side of the image. This is a very pleasing combination of several images. Dec 6th
4 Dec 23 Comment Guy, I did something with that iron post for you! To my eye that eliminates a huge distraction that was pulling my eye away from "the party." The lighthouse and foghorns on the left side,

To me this "perspective" image gets better when you separate the lighthouse from the foghorns as I did in the VF. In my mind it really makes one wonder how big those fog horns really are!

I like this image and what you were after. It was fun to play with as well. Thanks for sharing. Happy Holidays!
Dec 4th
4 Dec 23 Comment Erik, you truly are a master of bird photography. Above and beyond the camera settings you know where to go, when to go, where to stand and when to shoot. I look forward to more trips with you to continue to learn from the "sensei!"
Dec 4th
4 Dec 23 Comment Isaac as you said, three really great images from iPhones this month. For me, I love the reflection of both the tree and the sky in the water on the beach. I believe this really adds to the foreground. I took the liberty of getting rid of some of the small distracting branches at the left edge of the picture. That keeps my eye from drifting to the edge. Nice shot! Dec 3rd
4 Dec 23 Reply I know what you mean about the changes in business policy. When I was at EK accepting a gift of any kind from a customer or supplier was Taboo. Then at Ohio State - no one cared! Different world. Now I have no connection either way, just a close friend. I buy dinner and he provides the seats Oh, BTW thanks for the suggestion on the skate marks. Looking forward to doing some shooting with you in Florida this winter. Dec 3rd

6 comments - 3 replies for Group 4


6 comments - 3 replies Total


110 Images Posted

  = Current Round   = Previous Round
Group 04

Apr 26

Mar 26

Feb 26

Jan 26

Dec 25

Nov 25

Oct 25

Sep 25

Aug 25

Jul 25

Jun 25

May 25

Apr 25

Mar 25

Feb 25

Jan 25

Dec 24

Nov 24

Oct 24

Sep 24

Aug 24

Jul 24

Jun 24

May 24

Apr 24

Mar 24

Feb 24

Jan 24

Dec 23

Nov 23

Oct 23

Sep 23

Aug 23

Jul 23

Jun 23

May 23

Apr 23

Mar 23

Feb 23

Jan 23

Dec 22

Nov 22

Oct 22

Sep 22

Aug 22

Jul 22

Jun 22

May 22

Apr 22

Mar 22

Feb 22

Jan 22

Dec 21

Nov 21

Oct 21

Sep 21

Aug 21

Jul 21

Jun 21

May 21

Apr 21

Mar 21
Group 36

Feb 19
Group 46

Sep 18

Aug 18

Jul 18

Jun 18

May 18

Apr 18

Mar 18

Feb 18

Jan 18

Dec 17

Nov 17

Oct 17

Sep 17

Aug 17

Jul 17

Jun 17

May 17

Mar 17

Apr 17

Feb 17

Jan 17
Group 88

Apr 21

Mar 21

Feb 21

Jan 21

Dec 20

Nov 20

Oct 20

Sep 20

Aug 20

Jul 20

Jun 20

May 20

Apr 20

Mar 20

Feb 20

Jan 20

Dec 19

Nov 19

Oct 19

Sep 19

Aug 19

Jul 19

Jun 19

May 19

Apr 19

Mar 19

Close this Tab when done