Activity for User 1852 - Robin Mellor - rfmellor@icloud.com

avatar
Avatar

Close this Tab when done


191 Comments / 36 Replies Posted

  = Current Round   = Previous Round
Group Round C/R Comment Date Image
41 Feb 26 Comment I love the feeling that behind us is a ship whose crane is suspending this box over the, somewhat, turbulent water. The girl's mask add a necessary anonymity and the whole is a beautifully constructed fantasy. Thank you. Feb 22nd
41 Feb 26 Comment Very good effect using this technique. The red is a bit overwhelming, but a good colour. Perhaps if you faded the red off at the edges it would help bring the eye to the yellow at the centre, Feb 22nd
41 Feb 26 Comment I love the concept of the bird dragging the canyon off with it. The left side shows the tearing and dragging of reality as it gives up this piece of earth. I agree Nadia's frame helps. Well done. Feb 22nd
41 Feb 26 Reply Thank you, Ian. I enjoy the challenge of these things - keeps the dementia at bay! Feb 12th

3 comments - 1 reply for Group 41

99 Feb 26 Reply It's a technique I use quite a lot. I think (on the whole) keeping figures anonymous adds mystery and power. Recently I heard a camera club judge say he preferred people coming towards him. Oh well! Feb 22nd
99 Feb 26 Comment The portrait format is just right for this. I love the background and you have balanced flash and daylight really well. I'd be surprised if this doesn't;t do well in competition. Feb 22nd
99 Feb 26 Comment The figure is in the perfect place, the line of the dune at his feet leads the eye into the rest of the composition. He looks as if he is stood on a hard standing platform of some sort. If so it slightly spoi;s the wilderness aspect. But a great picture, nonetheless. Feb 22nd
99 Feb 26 Comment A clear and interrelated juxtaposition of natural and man-made elements. The trees make a good frame that leads the eye in. IR gives it all an otherworldly feeling. Feb 22nd
99 Feb 26 Comment I like the way you have caught the rain and the composition you have chosen. A fine record of 'crazy' people doing their thing. Feb 22nd
99 Feb 26 Comment I'm afarid I'm not taken with this picture. I see what you are getting at, but feel the pose is awkward - partly because of the angle you have taken it from - and does not flatter this young dancer. I think the point about the shoes could be better made with a closer framing of her legs and feet. But then, photographs mean different things to all of us, so take no notice of me. Feb 22nd
99 Feb 26 Comment You have caught the texture of the snow, which is not easy to do. There are many downsides to heavy snow but one upside is its pictorial qualities, of which you have taken good advantage. Feb 22nd

6 comments - 1 reply for Group 99


9 comments - 2 replies Total


20 Images Posted

  = Current Round   = Previous Round
Group 18

Nov 25

Oct 25

Sep 25

Aug 25

Jul 25

Jun 25

May 25

Apr 25

Mar 25

Feb 25

Jan 25

Dec 24

Nov 24

Oct 24
Group 41

May 26

Apr 26

Mar 26

Feb 26

Jan 26

Dec 25

Close this Tab when done