Activity for User 1852 - Robin Mellor - rfmellor@icloud.com

avatar
Avatar

Close this Tab when done


124 Comments / 23 Replies Posted

  = Current Round   = Previous Round
Group Round C/R Comment Date Image
18 Mar 25 Comment I like the way you have made the spheres different in size giving an effect of depth. There is a story here, and questions. Is this a scene from outer space with a planet consuming entity closing in? Or is it a deep sea scene where the strange inhabitants of the deep are in their continual life cycle? This is a treat for the eyes and the imagination. Mar 21st
18 Mar 25 Comment I agree that the log is too bright. I like the painterly effect, but, you know what?, I like your original too. The dark branch end on the log is crying out for a peeping fairy, or a troll face, or a hand reaching out . . . Mar 21st
18 Mar 25 Comment I agree with Ian about black and white. I'm note sure it needs the texture in the sky, sometimes simple is better. I know you love brushes - but why not use real birds? It is fun to be creative like this. Mar 21st
18 Mar 25 Comment The effect certainly enhances this interesting decorative feature. I like the saturation too. Mar 21st

4 comments - 0 replies for Group 18

99 Mar 25 Comment I did comment last week but it seems to have disappeared, so here goes again. This is another example of your excellent eye for a picture. As Maude says, it triggers the imagination, as well as pleasing the eye. I like the way you show how many people these days are so engrossed with their phones they miss all the wonderful things around them - for example the view reflected in the window, but to be fair she might be photographing something else interesting. See how your picture gets the imagination going. I like the extra tension of the figure being on the edge of the frame. You know what I would say about the tone and contrast, so I don't need to do so now. Mar 25th
99 Mar 25 Reply Mark, I bow to your military experience, and agree re. the vignette. I chose the angle of the vehicle as a more dramatic one than a side view. Mar 20th
99 Mar 25 Comment Wonderful layering in this landscape. The sea, the island, two layers of mountains and more layers of cloud. Wonderful. I like the contrast of this image and yet you have not lost the detail in the darkest parts. Lovely. Perfect black and white. Mar 20th
99 Mar 25 Comment Your excellent processing has brought out all the detail beautifully. The slight suggestion of a smokey background fits with the biker dive ethos. Good work. Mar 20th
99 Mar 25 Comment A very graphic representation of a cat with an evil stare. A good story too; are the bars holding it in? (it looks scary enough to be imprisoned) or keeping it out. And what is it up to? The treatment shows how a minimalist composition can still say a lot. Mar 20th
99 Mar 25 Comment Excellent composite. You have blended the escalators and the walls very beautifully. There is also a good story since usually one descends into the underworld. Why is this character allowed out? What's in his shopping bag? This picture is a feast for the eye and the imagination. (I too like the work of Jerry Ueslmann.) Mar 20th
99 Mar 25 Comment I like the water at the bottom holding everything up, and the way the spray echoes the clouds. In contrast there are the man made structures that seem out of place in the natural world. Great picture for the eye to explore. Mar 20th

6 comments - 1 reply for Group 99


10 comments - 1 reply Total


13 Images Posted

  = Current Round   = Previous Round
Group 18

Oct 25

Sep 25

Aug 25

Jul 25

Jun 25

May 25

Apr 25

Mar 25

Feb 25

Jan 25

Dec 24

Nov 24

Oct 24

Close this Tab when done