Activity for User 1013 - Larry Treadwell - treadwl@comcast.net

avatar
Avatar

Close this Tab when done


1542 Comments / 1171 Replies Posted

  = Current Round   = Previous Round
Group Round C/R Comment Date Image
7 Oct 19 Comment I've always had a romantic feeling toward these ancient behemoths and this images captures what is in my imagination. For me it is the curve of the tracks for a setting and this followed by the dense smoke with all the detail belching from the stack. The romance of the rails, the nostalgia of yesteryear---yep, you got it all. This is beautiful.
Oct 4th

1 comment - 0 replies for Group 7

11 Oct 19 Comment I'm a sucker for photos of the Milky Way. I love the shot, but I love the story better. (a males point of view) Oct 4th

1 comment - 0 replies for Group 11

13 Oct 19 Comment This is really a beautiful image. The calm warm tones create such a feeling of peace and tranquility. The inclusion of the dock keeps this from being just an ordinary sunset and makes it a work of art.

If it were mine, I'd crop out the tree on the right. To me it just feels out of place.
Oct 4th

1 comment - 0 replies for Group 13

17 Oct 19 Comment Winter is not about blankets of fresh white snow. This is the reality of winter. While it is full of solitude is also radiates the feeling of cold. The curving hanging branch of the tree makes a fine frame for this image.

If I had to suggest any change it may be to crop a little off the bottom as that large rock might be a little bit dominate.

This is quite well done.
Oct 4th

1 comment - 0 replies for Group 17

33 Oct 19 Comment Hi Ken
I was alerted to this image by Stephen so thought I'd drop by to see what you achieved. Having been to Acadia (would love to get back there) I'm well aware of the waves on the rocks.
I think (even without the face) that this has a feel of real power. This is almost like having a double explosion--the one coming forward and the vertical one behind it. Shots like this that show the power of the ocean are my favorites.

I wonder of some selected clarity and sharpening might bring out more texture in the spray.

You also might straighten the horizon. :-)

Overall, I really like the punch of this shot.
Do you have a shot of the round black rocks on the beach from Acadia?
Oct 8th

1 comment - 0 replies for Group 33

38 Oct 19 Comment I think you really managed to get the fury of a boomer crashing on the rocks. There is nothing quite like that boom and this photo creates the feel of that moment. Oct 29th

1 comment - 0 replies for Group 38

67 Oct 19 Reply Thanks for stopping by to comment. Maybe we will meet sometime at Blowing Rocks as I go there fairly often. Oct 29th
67 Oct 19 Comment "I guess I'll have to get up." I can just hear this lioness beginning her day if if it is a bit late. But if you have been out hunting all night I guess there is an excuse.

This is one of those images that makes the viewer just smile and that mental engagement makes the image stronger. I feel you did everything necessary to capture the image correctly and that you did in not over process it post.

Your crop from the original is effective and I'm glad you removed that unnecessary skyline from the original. I kind of feel this would be more powerful and draw the eye of the viewer much more if you have made this a vertical crop. I feel this way because there is very little action so by focusing the viewer more on the cat it would add strength to the image while still retaining some of the environment. One other thing that may make the image stronger would be if you were at ground level and eye to eye with the cat. Then you would really have some drama added to the image and also give more power to the cat. Those low angles are really more powerful.
Oct 18th
67 Oct 19 Reply Thanks for the "other-worldly" review.
When I took this I had a little bit of space the top but it was sky and I really felt it did nothing to add to the composition. This type of image with the crashing waves does not work well with focus stack--too much spray I really didn't want the sea behind the rocks to compete so DOF was not a real issue. The sea was also withing the range of my hyperfocal distance and besides the shutter speed insured that it would be soft anyway. I find your comment about fiber optics interesting because it is the same one I had when I saw this on the computer. The new wrinkle was trying to use the reflector to bounce some light back to the rocks. I was really shocked at how much of a difference it made compared to other shots I took.

Glad you enjoyed my ocean breeze. :-)
Oct 8th
67 Oct 19 Comment You have achieved a crisp image of the spider that shows off the colors and the beauty of this arachnid. However that heavily overexposed sunspot competes with the spider for attention. You could maintain the back light feeling and reduce the overexposed feeling by positioning the sun more behind the tree trunk. This would retain the "sun star" feeling while helping to retain the overexposed feeling. Also by stopping down the lens to f22 would also reduce the size of the sun's orb while maintaining the star. All of this would reduce the sun's competition with the spider and at the same time make the spider more dominate. This would require a slightly higher ISO but your camera can handle the increase without introducing noise. Oct 4th
67 Oct 19 Comment You have certainly captured a fine portrait of a"Majestic" animal. The background her compliments the wilderness feeling of this moose in the wild. I like how the rustic tones of the foliage are picked up in the tints of the moose along his flank and in the impressive rack. The damp coat also lends to this feeling.

My only suggestion involves the crop. This very tight crop enhances the portrait feel of the image however with the wonderful colors in this wilderness scene I would prefer to give the moose a bit more room to breathe within the frame. Expanding the frame woud not reduce the pop of the moose as here is enough space between the moose and the background to it out of focus and not bring in any distractions.
Oct 4th
67 Oct 19 Comment While I was in Acadia NP I took in this same scene and thus felt a nostalgic tug on my heart strings while enjoying this image. I think you came up with a solid composition that certainly enhanced your stated objective. It is a pleasure to find a photographer who also exposes for the highlights in their work. I feel this technique makes for more dramatic images and this is certainly one. I like your use of diagonal lines to impart motion and drama to the image as the created leading lines move the viewer through the image.

It may be my eye playing tricks but I feel the horizon is not quite level and could be adjusted easily in Lightroom. For me the entire image feels a bit soft and there seems to be a lot of blur in the foliage on the right. I would say this is the result of the long exposure however the rocks on the left are also a bit soft. Was it windy and perhaps that shook your tripod? I had a real problem with the wind in Acadia and had to wedge my tripod into the rocks to keep it still.

It is also a pleasure to see that you really use the tools of Lightroom to enhance your images. The double use of gradient masks shows your critical eye and creative impulse. This is really a fine image.
Oct 4th

4 comments - 2 replies for Group 67

72 Oct 19 Comment Oh my goodness!! I really like the drama of this flying dust. It feel like the elephant is emerging from this storm of dust and coming right at me. This is a quite dramatic and powerful image. Well done.


Thought I would play with this fantastic image just a bit.
Added some clarity, selected sharpness and did a bit of dodging and burning on the elephant.
Oct 8th

1 comment - 0 replies for Group 72

81 Oct 19 Comment Stephen encouraged me to visit and see your wave photo. You may not have gotten to where you wanted to be by this is still an effective photo. I don't think I ever seen so much of a trailing plume of spray as you captured in this shot. You did quite well. Oct 29th

1 comment - 0 replies for Group 81


12 comments - 2 replies Total


156 Images Posted

  = Current Round   = Previous Round
Group 36

Oct 25

Sep 25

Aug 25

Jul 25

Jun 25

May 25

Apr 25

Mar 25

Feb 25

Jan 25

Dec 24

Nov 24

Oct 24

Sep 24

Aug 24

Jul 24

Jun 24

May 24

Apr 24

Mar 24

Feb 24

Jan 24

Dec 23

Nov 23

Oct 23

Sep 23

Aug 23

Jul 23

Jun 23

May 23

Apr 23

Mar 23

Feb 23

Jan 23

Dec 22

Nov 22

Oct 22

Sep 22

Aug 22

Jul 22

Jun 22

May 22

Apr 22

Mar 22

Feb 22

Jan 22

Dec 21

Nov 21

Oct 21

Sep 21

Aug 21

Jul 21

Jun 21

May 21

Apr 21

Mar 21

Feb 21

Jan 21

Dec 20

Nov 20

Oct 20

Sep 20

Aug 20

Jul 20

Jun 20

May 20

Apr 20

Mar 20

Feb 20

Jan 20
Group 67

Oct 25

Sep 25

Aug 25

Jul 25

Jun 25

May 25

Apr 25

Mar 25

Feb 25

Jan 25

Dec 24

Nov 24

Oct 24

Sep 24

Aug 24

Jul 24

Jun 24

May 24

Apr 24

Mar 24

Feb 24

Jan 24

Dec 23

Nov 23

Oct 23

Sep 23

Aug 23

Jul 23

Jun 23

May 23

Apr 23

Mar 23

Feb 23

Jan 23

Dec 22

Nov 22

Oct 22

Sep 22

Aug 22

Jul 22

Jun 22

May 22

Apr 22

Mar 22

Feb 22

Jan 22

Dec 21

Nov 21

Oct 21

Sep 21

Aug 21

Jul 21

Jun 21

May 21

Apr 21

Mar 21

Feb 21

Jan 21

Dec 20

Nov 20

Oct 20

Sep 20

Aug 20

Jul 20

Jun 20

May 20

Apr 20

Mar 20

Feb 20

Jan 20

Dec 19

Nov 19

Oct 19

Sep 19

Aug 19

Jul 19

May 19

Jun 19

Apr 19

Mar 19

Feb 19

Jan 19

Dec 18

Nov 18

Oct 18
Group 89

Jun 20

Close this Tab when done